23 Comments
User's avatar
Leslie Gelb's avatar

I SO get the living in NYC - made me feel a bit nostalgic… India! Exciting! Xo

Expand full comment
Melissa's avatar

Die hard New Yorker here ( albeit with a house to escape in the Catskills). First of all- next time you come, you'll go to Daytona Trimmings in the district. Still going strong with two cats that prowl the aisles !Second- India is amazing and totally wack! I've been there four times Would go back tomorrow., Happy to send you my recs. ( and BTW- the contemporary Indian fashion scene is amazo!)

Expand full comment
Susan Orlean's avatar

Please send any recommendations! Shopping tips especially welcome. Thanks!

Expand full comment
Sharon A's avatar

"the efflorescence of scaffolding" -- I adore this!

Expand full comment
Jennifer Ward Dudley's avatar

Garment district ?! I never went downtown nyc except for the village. Moved from home city LA when I was 21. Lived 783 Madison Ave. 5 floor walk up. Worked temp jobs . Most Ad agencies and film production. Crazy , wonderful mid 1970’s. Sex was alive and especially well. What a time to be alive ! Happy Turkey

Expand full comment
J. Alexander Stevens's avatar

Excellent read.

Expand full comment
Glencora's avatar

Strongly recommend Colton Whitehead’s “The Colossus of New York” and specifically this chapter about, well, all of this.

https://www.nytimes.com/2001/11/11/magazine/the-way-we-live-now-11-11-01-lost-and-found.html

Expand full comment
Bill Barol's avatar

Yeah. That's a really wonderful piece about being part of the NY diaspora. (My slice of time there was 1980-89.)

Expand full comment
Glencora's avatar

Ugh, *Colson - no edit button

Expand full comment
Leslie Carroll's avatar

Oh, no! NOT M&J trimming, too!!!! From high school onward, I frequented them for everything, from trim to tassels to buttons -- and that whole neighborhood was once the feather & flower district ... (floral crowns and headbands were a thing when I was in high school so I made my own instead of spending $$$ to buy store-bought); and years later when I had my own non-profit classical theatre company, M&J was the best place to source period-looking trimming for everything from medieval tabards to Edwardiana.

Expand full comment
Susan Orlean's avatar

Sadly, it’s true. End of an era.

Expand full comment
Glencora's avatar

Oh dang, I was just there in the fall! I miss all the bead/finding shops on 6th. At least Toho still exists, near Bryant Park now.

I really dislike change, which is an unfortunate trait in someone who still considers herself an adoptive New Yorker, and is a devoted reader of New York history.

Expand full comment
Dwelling in Possibility's avatar

That scaffolding became law through the death of a student at Barnard, Grace Gold, who was killed by falling scaffolding from a Columbia building in the spring of 1979. At first Local Law 10, put in place through the lobbying of Grace's sister, Lori, required building owners to check their scaffolding. It morphed into a law requiring the protective scaffolding on buildings under construction. I grew up in Brooklyn and went to high school with the Gold sisters; it's hard to remember a time before the ubiquitous scaffolding but indeed that's what it looked like like until the 80s. https://www.habitatmag.com/Archive2/362-January-2019/The-Tragedy-That-Changed-the-Face-of-the-City

Expand full comment
Ted Travelstead's avatar

NYC 1993-2013. Best years, worst years, wouldn’t trade it for the world.

Expand full comment
Glencora's avatar

Yes, perfect. There was still enough gross yucky stuff in Times Square/midtown to remind you you were in a major city, but it was cleaned up enough you could walk around at night without being extra concerned for your safety, even while drunk and making poor life decisions, or so I’ve heard. 😶

Expand full comment
Annabel Youens's avatar

Muji - I feel that so much...I want to organize everything!

Expand full comment
Neal Stiffelman's avatar

“the efflorescence of scaffolding” — Wow!

Expand full comment
Steph's avatar

I noticed there were no comments on Stereophonic - intentional?

Expand full comment
Susan Orlean's avatar

I was a little underwhelmed. Good but not great, in my opinion. I don’t like criticizing a show or really any creative endeavor unless I’m going to write about it at length, so I was being quiet about my disappointment.

Expand full comment
Melissa's avatar

A solid show. Perhaps a wee bit longer than it needed to be and maybe not the greatest show to ever hit Broadway. But solid.

Expand full comment
Nalini Dovedy's avatar

Have fun in india.

Expand full comment
Nancy Klopper's avatar

Enjoy that trip to India!!!!

Expand full comment
Eric Friedman's avatar

I’m leaving a link to a Dave Frishberg song that puts words and melody to some of the always resonant sentiments you so eloquently express here.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2zxilQVp_4

Expand full comment